Podcast: Parsing the Charter Revision Questions on This Year’s Ballot

More

Eric Thunem

This week on 0684-Radi0, our free podcast (subscribe here in the iTunes Store), we talk to Eric Thunem, a member of the Town Council, about six questions on the ballot this year regarding proposed changes to New Canaan’s Charter, the founding document of the town. Here’s a link to the Charter Revision Commission’s report.

Here are recent episodes of 0684-Radi0:

17 thoughts on “Podcast: Parsing the Charter Revision Questions on This Year’s Ballot”

  1. Thanks for having this conversation.

    I asked this question at the Lapham meeting and did not quite get an answer. What is the *scope* of the First Selectman’s power under the first ballot question? Would the First Selectman, if the referendum passed, have the power to fire an elected official? And if not outright fire, then lean on, exercise undue influence over, create a hostile work environment in hopes of eliciting a resignation, etc.?

    To be clear, I am not suggesting Dionna Carlson would do anything of the kind. All due respect to Councilman Thune, it seems shortsighted to say, “I can’t imagine a rogue First Selectman” in the future doing something heinous. At this time in the U.S., is that so unimaginable?

    Seems a referendum is the electorate’s time to think like a Supreme Court and consider possible scenarios, not to adopt a mindset of “We’re a nice town, [unfortunate behavior] wouldn’t happen here.” Instead, it seems we have the responsibility to ensure it cannot happen here.

  2. I was hoping to hear about the problems that these proposed revisions would solve and why they were needed. I heard nothing about that despite Mike’s clear and direct questioning.

  3. The question is why is this Charter amendment necessary? Are Town officers and managers NOT responding to directives of the First Selectman, and this is an attempt to bring them under the First Selectman’s control? Have there been problems where the Town officers and managers and the First Selectmen disagreed on an issue of importance and a final decider was needed to settle the matter?

    I would love for someone to point to an instance where there the ambiguous line of authority that apparently exists in the Charter has caused some damage to the Town or its citizens. The speaker was clearly unable to do so.

  4. Offering some context and personal thoughts regarding Ballot Question #1:

    Consider this – if you are a manager of Town employees – whether you are elected official (First Selectman, Town Clerk, Registrar of Voters, Town Treasurer) or an appointed one (Assessor, Tax Collector, Director of Public Works, Town Engineer, or CFO) – you should follow the same written HR principles and protocols in managing your staff.

    The Town Charter has not historically spelled this out and while it makes sense that our Town employees should expect to be managed under the same policies – e.g. work-hour rules, budget timelines, security protocols and ethics standards – the Town Charter has not been codified as such. In some cases, written administrative and operational directives have been interpreted as not being applicable to everyone or that elected officials should be independent from these policies.

    The Charter amendment proposed in Ballot Question #1 addresses what elected and appointed managers are responsible for in their managerial duties of municipal employees. Elected and appointed positions change over time, the Charter should not be subject to interpretation which may differ whenever there is position turnover. This proposed Charter amendment provides for clarity and consistency so that all Town Hall employees can expect fair and equal employment guidelines in any department in which they work. At the same time, the amendment specifically clarifies that such policies would not undermine the statutory authority of any manager – whether an elected or appointed official.

    The proposed amendment does not expand the power of any First Selectman. The Town Charter already states that a First Selectman is the chief executive and the chief administrative officer – responsibilities that involve oversight of operational and administrative policies for any organization. The amendment ensures that these policies are uniformly applied by those with managerial responsibility.

    • Kathleen — have known you for a long time and respect what you have
      done for the Town — it was you and the company that you worked for that found the BOE secret bank accounts with Millions of dollars in them.
      Many many years ago.
      But you know as well as I do that there is this hostility the first selectmen
      has for the Town Clerck. And this is an effort to exert control over Her.

      Vote NO Question 1

  5. The First Selectman does not have the authority to “fire an elected official”. Further, to “create a hostile work environment” as defined under the Connecticut Fair Employment Practices Act is a violation of State Law, and there are several legal and financial remedies available to those who become subject to such an environment.

  6. I believe it is important to ensure that her authority remains within the limits established by law and that appropriate checks and balances are maintained. Clear oversight and accountability help ensure that power is exercised responsibly, fairly, and in the best interests of everyone involved.

  7. I am 100% in agreement with Kathleen Corbet’s comments. There’s no question that the First Selectman is the CEO and CAO of the Town. Nor is it controversial that certain officers or other entities are be partially accountable to the Town and partially independent of the Town–that’s the case for the School District, for example. No official of the Town–elected or otherwise–operates entirely independently of the Town, nor should they. It seems to me that the only real question here is whether the Charter Commission and Town Council should have provided a blow-by-blow history of why the issue is up for consideration. The decision to spare the public–and the officials involved–from all that reflects sound leadership by our First Selectman, The Charter Review Commission and the Town Council. There’s no need to litigate details when the policy reflected in the proposed change is self-evidently sound.

  8. I recommend all voters go into town hall and ask any employee how toxic the work environment is under the current executive administration. I can’t imagine taking recourse away from town hall employees and giving the first selectman unchecked control. So let’s not move backward and take away the little amount of checks and balances that still exist. This ballot item was never discussed at the public hearings and is a concocted power grab by the executive branch’s For the sake of town hall employee moral you must vote NO!!!!

  9. Apparently we need a charter to explain the Town Charter. Let’s be honest: 95% of voters will show up with no clue what the six ballot questions mean. And no matter how they vote, life in New Canaan will look exactly the same on Wednesday morning.

  10. I agree with Richard, most residents pay no attention to the Charter unless it personally affects an issue in play. Having said as much, it is a very worthy document to be considered when running the Town. The disagreements and differences of opinion in the CRC are worth the time, energy and debate to get it right.
    I believe the most significant change in this Charter is to require Town Council approval of Town-owned real property. This motion passed in the CRC the end of April and unanimously by the Town Council in July. I thought it was long overdue to give residents a voice in issues like cell towers, lease of Vine Cottage, lease of the Police Station, proposed sites for low income housing and changes to our Parks. To be clear we had no idea of a proposed CCRC in Waveny at the time.
    As for Ballot Number 1, I abstained. I was concerned that internal conflicts might result in legal consequences. It can always be better but it has worked well enough for a very long time.

  11. In addition to the problems with Charter Question 1, people should also consider voting NO on Charter Question 4. Under current rules, Board of Finance members have to be real property owners, but Charter Question 4 would allow non-property owners to be on the Board of Finance. Almost all the tax revenue from the town comes from real estate taxes. Currently, if the Board of Finance thinks the town should spend more money, it means that they personally will also have to pay more taxes. This means that they have skin in the game and that they are incentivized to be more responsible in their budget decisions. By changing this rule, we will have people on the Board of Finance who benefit from more spending but don’t have to bear the burden of more taxes. This will lead to more profligate spending. Please vote NO on Question 4.

  12. As I understand #4, voting NO means those who set the town mill rate will continue to be personally affected by that rate. Skin in the game. Vote No!

  13. With all due respect to my colleague, Mr Thunem, his comments on this podcast reflect his personal views and not that of the Town Council per our Town Council Rules, Article IV, Board Ethics which state “whenever a member makes a public statement on an issue relating to Town government, other than in a meeting of the Council or a committee of subcommittee thereof, the member shall make clear that he or she is not speaking on behalf of the Council.”

    Voters Deserve Clarity on Charter Ballot Questions

    My comments are in my capacity as an individual resident and I am not writing on behalf of the Town Council:

    I believe voters deserve clear, fair, and neutral explanations of proposed Charter changes before being asked to vote on them. The upcoming Charter ballot questions raise important issues about transparency and informed decision-making. In the absence of explanatory text, I will attempt to clarify some key concepts as I’ve seen voters asking for this in multiple forums.

    Question 1: Explain the Rationale for the Proposed Change
    I voted against Question 1 on August 12, 2026 and continue to oppose it as written.
    Question 1 asks:
    “Shall the current Charter be changed to require all elected and appointed Town officers with managerial authority to comply with applicable Town policies, ethics standards and lawful administrative directions and be accountable to the First Selectman for administrative and operational matters that would not otherwise conflict with their statutory authority?”
    I asked that the ballot question include a reference to consistency with the requirements applicable to Town employee managers, which I believe was the intent of the Charter Revision Commission (CRC). More broadly, however, the question does not adequately explain why this change is being proposed or what problem it is intended to address.
    The CRC report does not clearly identify who proposed this amendment, when it was introduced, which meeting considered it, or the specific rationale for placing it before voter. Residents deserve to understand the purpose and potential implications of a proposed change to the administrative authority and accountability of elected officials.
    The focus of Ballot Question One is the Town Clerk and the Registrar of Voters. Placing these elected officials in charge of elections and their employees under the authority of the First Selectman compromises election integrity, the integrity of town records, future referenda, and overall integrity of the functions they perform, especially if these functions may or may not conflict with the interests of any First Selectman. The CEO of the Town aka the First Selectman is tasked, sans Charter directives, with forging a positive, cooperative and respectful relationship with these elected officers and executive authority should NOT be codified into the Charter, which has existed since 1935 with no such provisions. Separation of powers and checks and balances exist in our town government structure to augment public trust and ensure fairness to all residents regardless of political affiliation.

    Question 6: More Than Technical Housekeeping
    On August 12, 2026, I voted in favor of Ballot Question 6 with the expectation that the Town Council would subsequently meet to vote to approve clear, fair, and neutral explanatory text for all ballot questions crafted by the Town Clerk and Town Attorney. That meeting to approve the text never occurred. As a result, I no longer support Question 6 as presented to voters, and I believe my change in position deserves explanation.
    Question 6 asks:
    “Shall the current Charter be changed to clarify deviations, delete outdated references and update provisions to current practice?”
    This broad, catch-all language does not tell voters which specific Charter provisions they are being asked to approve. The approximately 75-page Charter Revision Commission report and ballot questions are not linked in any way and there is no clear numbering or cross-referencing system that would allow residents to readily connect the ballot language to the proposed changes. Nor does the question define what constitutes a deviation, an outdated reference, or a provision that needs to be updated to reflect current practice.
    These are not necessarily minor, technical changes. Some affect the roles and responsibilities of Town government, including provisions that expand the powers and duties of the Board of Selectmen with regards to the personnel matters even though union contracts are negotiated every 3 years – the charter lasts for ten years. Inputting provisions into the Charter that a union can renegotiate every 3 years makes no sense. Another proposed change removes the Board of Selectmen’s role in the dismissal of part-time and seasonal employees, who are not represented by a union. Voting yes on Question 6 allows department heads to dismiss young adult lifeguards and camp counselors with no layer of oversight by our Board of Selectman. It happens so infrequently, why is this change needed? The Board of Selectman should be involved to make sure our youth are being fairly represented and that sound judgment is being exercised on their behalf.

    Among the provisions that warrant specific identification and explanation are Article IX, C98-4(C), Powers and Duties of the Fire Commission, pages 54–55; Article XV, C154-1, Employees under the jurisdiction of Selectman, page 62; Article XVII, Police Commission, Powers and Duties, C 174, Sections A and D, page 65; Article XIX, C192 and C193, Public Works Department page 67; and Article XX, Town Clerk, C211, page 69.

    At the August 12 Town Council special meeting, I sought to separate the “update provisions to current practice” language into a distinct ballot question so that voters could consider these changes independently rather than approving a broad collection of amendments under one question; however, that change was not approved. Voting No on Question 6 allows current practices to allow a fluid and responsive government in line with changing union contracts, maintains the independence of Police and Fire Departments and Commissions for the next decade, and protects our youngest workers with no union representation.

    Transparency Is Essential
    Voters should not have to decipher a lengthy report to understand the potential consequences of their vote. Residents should be given sufficient and concise information to make an informed decision.
    Charter revisions can have lasting consequences for how our town is governed. Regardless of how individual residents may vote on these questions, they should be able to do so with a clear understanding of what each amendment would change and why.
    Good government requires more than placing questions on a ballot. It requires giving voters the information they need to make informed choices about their town’s future.
    Kimberly Norton

  14. All of this discussion is genuinely helpful to read, and while I have already voted, much of it confirms choices I made. But I had the luxury of time to dig into the charter questions before I went to the polls. I have received panicked text messages from people leaving the polls who didn’t have that time. This comment thread, oddly, offers the exact context that voters would have benefited from seeing before early voting opened.

    Also, a linguistic nit, because it bugs me and I can’t help myself when there’s an inaccurate analogy at play. A First Selectman isn’t really a CEO. A CEO answers to a corporate board of governors. A mayor, First Selectman, or any elected executive serves his or her electorate. I think we need to maintain that distinction to keep an objective understanding of governance.

  15. I’ve decided I won’t be voting on the Charter revision ballot questions this year. After watching the process unfold, it feels less like a straightforward update to the Town Charter and more like a political tug‑of‑war among people with their own agendas. The discussion around these questions has become so tangled and so charged that it’s nearly impossible for an average voter to understand what they’re actually approving or rejecting.

    It also seems that if these initiatives are approved, they would create more bureaucracy and concentrate more control in the hands of a limited group of people. The Town Council already botched the leaf‑blower ordinance, do we really want to give them more control?

    I’m not going to pretend I understand the full implications of these proposals when the process itself has made clarity so hard to find. So this year, I’m sitting out the ballot questions. When revisions to our governing document become this confusing, this politicized, and this opaque, the safest vote is no vote at all.

  16. I’m voting NO on all six. No change to the charter at all until we are given sufficient and concise information to make an informed decision. Thank you Kim. Not voting at all could help those voting yes

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *