New Canaan Now & Then: The Playhouse

In 1922, when the New Canaan Playhouse was built, current day Elm Street (then Railroad Avenue) was vacant land, except for one resident on the south side.  A group of local men, The Village Improvement Company, recognized the need for a playhouse.  Their proposal included the opportunity for each and every resident to become a stockholder. 

The cupolaed building was designed by local resident, Calvin E. Kiessling. Kiessling’s design, the red brick and white trim, suggesting a  modified colonial structure, established the style for the future buildings that eventually filled in both sides of Elm Street. The building had a frontage of 58 feet on Railroad Avenue (Elm) and extended back 100 feet with flanking passageways on each side used in conjunction with the fourteen exits in addition to the exits off the main lobby. The original plans also called for two stores at street level. The auditorium itself was originally 56 feet wide and 76 feet deep, with a seating capacity of 400.

New Canaan Now & Then: Grace House in the Field

The New Canaan Country School campus has a long history of serving the needs of children and the majestic main campus building, Grace House in the Fields, has been an integral part of this legacy. Grace House was completed in April 1899. The columned portico was fronted by a dirt driveway lined with sugar maples. If you happen to drive up Frogtown Road, be sure to take notice of the size of these trees today. 

The NCCS acquired the property from the Grace Episcopal Church of New York in May 1936 as a new campus, having outgrown its prior location on Seminary Street. At the time of the acquisition, the St.

New Canaan Now & Then: The Thrift Shop

The next time you are waiting at the light on Locust Avenue take a minute to consider the interesting history of the building that currently houses the New Canaan Thrift Shop. This clapboard Greek revival home was built in 1840 by Joseph Scofield. Scofield purchased the property, “75 feet from the highway,” from Seymour Comstock for $150. Scofield, a prohibitionist, leased the two-story house to the Young Men’s Total Abstinence Society (later known as the Friendship Division of the Sons of Temperance). Unfortunately, Scofield had limited success with prohibition.  The upper floor of 2 Locust Avenue was used as a dance floor and boasted a vaulted ceiling that was painted to resemble the night sky.

New Canaan Now & Then: Ponus Ridge Chapel

The history of the Ponus Ridge Chapel begins in 1902 when a group from the Ponus Ridge area began to hold church services and a Sunday school in a butcher shop on Davenport Ridge.  

In 1907, the group formally organized as the Ponus Street Union Chapel, a non-denominational Christian group.  In their first meeting, a building committee was created to find land and build a dedicated meeting space.  Both Levi S. Weed and Charles E. Hubbell sold a part of their land to the committee for $1.  In total the parcel was 25′ by 100′.  The chapel itself was designed by Charles E. Hubbell and Charles A. Luckhurst both Ponus Ridge residents and architects.  The stone came from local farms, predominantly from the Thurton farm across the street.  

Two hundred people attended the chapel dedication on September 10, 1911.  It quickly became the center of the community for the area. Six weddings and a funeral were held in the chapel in its first forty years. Many local fairs were hosted from the chapel.  One such fair was centered around the dedication of a bell for the chapel.   Edward Lawerence married Fanny Davenport and so to replace the “belle” that he was taking from the ridge, he gave the chapel a bell in return.  During WWI, the chapel was used by the Ladies’ Aid Society for what is described as “Red Cross work.”  This group of women is most likely the group depicted in the picture above. By the 1930s, activities in the chapel had slowed down.

New Canaan Now & Then: Time Capsule

Earlier this week, Tucker Murphy, the Town’s Chief Administrative Officer, asked where the time capsule buried near the Wayside Cross was located. Searching through the New Canaan Museum & Historical Society’s records, we discovered that a time capsule was buried during the Town’s 200th anniversary held on September 29th, 2001. Because the Museum still had the VHS of this celebration, and a TV with a built-in VHS player, too, we could watch the events from 2001.  The ceremonies were held just weeks after 9/11, and many of the patriotic speeches reflected the town’s sense of loss and grieving.  The burial of the time capsule at God’s Acre received a relatively short mention, and the location remained unclear. 

However, with some sleuthing and additional research, we were able to identify that this time capsule was buried a few feet behind Wayside Cross in a carefully constructed hole lined with plywood and gravel.  The capsule, which is meant to be unearthed in 2051 for the Town’s 250th anniversary, holds fifty items including dance tickets to the New Canaan High School, a map of the Town and its parking lots, a telephone book, and newspaper clippings about the World Trade Center disaster.  

The real mystery, and what it turned out Tucker wanted, was a 1923 time capsule.  A few weeks before the 200th anniversary celebrations, work began to find this time capsule.  Its burial had been recorded in the May 31, 1923 edition of the Advertiser.  The ground around the Wayside Cross was thoroughly turned over, but eventually it was given up for lost. Thanks to this article, and some current day research, we now know the location of this 1923 time capsule.  The April 12, 1923 edition of the Advertiser states “the coffer will be lowered into the concrete foundation….”  (Rereading the May 31 edition, it does mention that the coffer was lowered into the foundation during Memorial Day celebrations.)  Unfortunately, there is no information on how the coffer was sealed in the foundation.  There is no mention of pouring concrete, lowering it into the wet concrete, or how it was sealed.  Therefore, it seems likely that the coffer is in its own chamber as there was originally a plan to drape the bronze coffer with an American flag.  

It is also of note that General John Thompson, the inventor of the Thompson submachine gun, gave a speech during the 1923 Memorial Day celebration.  Thompson and his wife first lived on Bank Street and later Brinkerhoff Avenue beginning in 1919.  Also at this 1923 celebration was the dedication of the cannon that stands outside Town Hall.  The cannon, most likely a Blakely rifle, was originally located on Governor’s Island in New York City and protected the city during the Civil War. When we wrote about the Wayside Cross in an earlier Then & Now article, we didn’t realize there had been two dedication ceremonies – the first on May 30, 1923, and the second on September 9 of the same year when the cross was finished.  The first ceremony took place on Memorial Day because the Town needed funds for the completion of the project.  Work on the base was about to begin and workers were well on their way on carving the cross.  A decision was made to generate interest – and possible donations – by filling a “bronze coffer” with items for future generations to find.  The contents are as follows:

Letter from President Harding*
Letter from General Pershing*
Letter from Connecticut Governor Templeton*
Autographed copy of President Wilson’s address to Congress declaring war with Germany
List of the soldiers from all wars
Engraved charter of the Veterans of Foreign Wars
List of members of the local branch of the Red Cross
Resolution from the Women’s Relief Corps donating $500 to the Wayside Cross project and listing charter members
List of sixty-three soldiers from St.